Overview
Le Moyne College is committed to an environment where freedom of inquiry and an open exchange of conflicting viewpoints is supported and encouraged. As a Jesuit institution, the manner in which Le Moyne students engage in civil discourse – regardless of content or viewpoints being expressed – is held to a high standard. Just as students are encouraged to engage in critical thought and social action, so are they expected to do so in a civil manner that honors the inherent dignity of all people, even those who may disagree. Therefore, demonstrations may not take place in a manner that endangers the College community, violates the law, is defamatory, constitutes a genuine threat or harassment, unjustifiably invades the rights of others, or interrupts the functioning of the College.
All Le Moyne students have the right to freedom of speech, expression and assembly, including but not limited to timely demonstrations in response to current events. Students are free to express their views individually or in organized groups, on any topic, subject only to the policies and procedures necessary to preserve the rights of others and the other functions of the College. For the purpose of this policy, the term “demonstration” will refer broadly to the organized display of these rights.
Members of the campus community are reminded that the free expression of ideas and viewpoints will foster an open exchange of ideas and opinions. Persons engaging in respectful protest should expect that others may disagree with them and voice their disagreement. This exchange of ideas is the hallmark of a pluralistic, healthy, and vibrant academic community.
Our Community Expectations
As a Jesuit and Catholic institution, Le Moyne College expects all community members to conduct themselves with respect, care, and thoughtfulness, especially when expressing diverse viewpoints on contentious issues. Expression that is indecent, grossly obscene, or objectively offensive—particularly on matters such as race, sex, color, national or ethnic origin (including shared ancestry and ethnic characteristics), age, religion, disability, marital status, sexual orientation, genetic information, military status, gender, or gender identity—is inconsistent with the College’s Community Standards and applicable federal and state laws (including Title VI and Title IX) and will not be tolerated.
In line with its commitment to fostering speech and expression, Le Moyne College respects the rights of all members of the academic community to explore, discuss, and express opinions, and to debate issues publicly in a civil, orderly, and safe manner. The College supports the right to voluntary assembly and strives to make facilities reasonably available for peaceful assembly.
The opportunity to express oneself is subject to reasonable restrictions on time, place, and manner, as outlined in the College's guidelines, and does not extend to unlawful activity. The authorized use of any College forum for expression does not imply acceptance or endorsement by the College of the views expressed. Le Moyne College will not permit 2 disruptive behavior or disorderly conduct that interrupts its proper operations or infringes upon the rights of others. Individuals engaging in such conduct will be subject to disciplinary action.
Guidelines for Demonstrations, Assembly, Rally and Protest
These guidelines pertain to demonstrations, protests, and other organized gatherings on Le Moyne property, during College-sponsored events, or using any other College controlled forum. Such demonstrations, protests, and gatherings must be organized and led by students; the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement, located in the Campus Life Office, will serve as the primary administrative contact for students. The first step in this process is to complete this form (Here) at least one business day or 48 hours prior to the planned event. The following are general requirements for demonstrations:
Sponsorship
Any Le Moyne student (currently registered for classes) may serve as a sponsor for a protest/demonstration on campus. Individuals, small groups of students and/or registered student organizations may plan a protest/demonstration on campus. In all cases, protest/demonstration organizers must meet with and register their event with the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement. For Registered Student Organizations (RSOs), the organizers must provide written documentation that they have met with their group advisor/moderator and obtained their agreement to provide direct support for the planned protest, in addition to meeting with the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement; for Affiliate Student Organizations (ASOs), the organizers must work with the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement.
Protest Registration Process
The first step in this process is to complete this form (Here) at least one business day or 48 hours prior to the planned event.
• Students must schedule this meeting with as much notice as possible following completion of the form. Notice will allow college staff time to work with the student(s) to assure the demonstration will abide by college guidelines and maximize the learning experience inherent in the process of a demonstration. Students should email the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement at [email protected], or visit the Campus Life Office.
• The purpose of the meeting is to review the details of the proposed demonstration including proposed time, place, manner, planned size, and location for the event. During this meeting the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement or their designee will set expectations, educate students on what constitutes dissent versus disruption, and express the consequences of violations.
• Reservation of outside campus space for any event will be contingent upon availability and should follow the guidelines and process established by Event Services. Student Engagement (or supporting offices) will help the student(s) coordinate the details and prepare for any additional needs (security, safety concerns, etc.). Tabling, handing out pamphlets, flyers, etc. may also be a form of protest/demonstration and must follow these guidelines. Produced posters, flyers, etc. 3 must be approved through the college posting policy. The distribution of materials must not impede the normal operations of the College nor community members’ ability to function in living, learning, and/or working on campus.
• The College has ultimate discretion to determine the most appropriate location on campus for an approved event.
• Counter-protesters may also submit the registration form, and the location of the counter-protest will be separated from the original protest to protect the health and safety of all involved.
Responsibility of Student Organizers
Once the details of the demonstration have been confirmed, student organizers, with support from the Office of Student Engagement, are responsible for notifying the Associate Provost for Student Development and the Director of Public Safety via email of the planned demonstration. Student organizers are also responsible for maintaining peace and order, which includes educating participants about the College’s expectations. Individuals or groups who organize the event are accountable for the conduct of their guests and may be subject to disciplinary action as the responsible party for violations of College policy incurred by their guests.
During a demonstration, the expression of viewpoints may invite or elicit a response from others, including counter-protestors or passersby. In all circumstances, others’ right to personal expression may not be denied. Organizers should be aware that other demonstrations may also be approved that may include opposing views. Maintaining peace and order is especially important under these circumstances to support a campus environment that is accepting of divergent expression. The College supports academic freedom and recognizes that not all speech and expression align with the College’s values and mission. Organizers should review the student handbook for College policies related to harassment, discrimination, bias incidents, hate speech, and bullying. Organizers will be referred to the Office of Student Conduct should incidents of harassment, discrimination bias, hate speech, bullying, or other conducted deemed inconsistent with community standards be reported.
Student organizers of demonstrations, protests, and other organized gatherings must ensure that they adhere to the College’s expectations regarding movement, involvement of outside organizations, noise levels, use of banners, construction of structures, participant behavior, and communication of event parameters.
Movement
• The demonstration permits the continued operation of College functions and is not disruptive-i.e., allows free movement about campus; allows classes and College-sponsored events to continue unhindered and uninterrupted (including no excessive noise in or near academic buildings); allows other students, faculty, administrators, staff, contractors, and visitors to conduct their business in academic, administrative, athletic, dining, and residence hall spaces; allows unimpeded entrance and egress from College buildings and grounds as needed.
• Demonstrations may not impede the free flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic, block thoroughfares, or obstruct campus building entry or exit points. Demonstrations may not employ force, violence or intimidation, or constitute an immediate threat of force or violence against person or property. Demonstrators may not possess or use projectiles, firearms, look-a-like firearms, ammunition, fireworks, explosives, dangerous chemicals, weapons, facsimiles or any symbols associated with hate crimes (i.e. swastikas, confederate flags, etc.), the display of which could reasonably be expected to violate applicable College antiharassment policies.
• Demonstrations must take place in the reserved location and any march/process around campus will be permitted outdoors only. Any intentions to march/process must be discussed with the Office of Student Engagement (or supporting department) and planned appropriately. Demonstrations will not be permitted inside residence halls, dining halls, athletic facilities, classrooms, or offices.
Outside Organizations
• Outside organizations are not permitted to demonstrate on College property without approval from the College. Any engagement with outside organizations should be addressed in the demonstration proposal.
Noise
• Demonstrations need to limit noise to reasonable levels that do not interfere with the learning environment of the campus. The ordinary business of the College needs to be able to continue without noise interference. Demonstrations are prohibited during final exams.
• Use of any voice projection (microphones, megaphone, etc.) must be pre-approved as part of the demonstration/protest registration process.
Banners and Structures
• Use of any banners, structures, furniture, or other free/permanent standing structures must follow the posting policy and be pre-approved by the Office of Student Engagement. No encampments or fixtures to the college grounds will be permitted.
• Demonstrations may not take place indoors or in any space that has been concurrently reserved by other members of the College community or guests. Private offices are not locations for demonstrations and reception areas must remain clear of traffic for egress. Demonstrators may enter private offices only with the permission of the occupant. The hours of building operations need to be observed and followed.
• Demonstrations may not impede the free flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic, block thoroughfares, or obstruct campus building entry or exit points. Demonstrations may not employ force, violence, or intimidation, or constitute an immediate threat of force or violence against person or property. 5 Demonstrators may not possess or use firearms, ammunition, fireworks, dangerous chemicals, weapons, facsimiles or any symbols associated with hate crimes (i.e. swastikas, confederate flags, etc.), the display of which could reasonably be expected to violate applicable College antiharassment policies.
Behaviors of Participants
• The demonstration respects and preserves College property, including building opening and closing times, facility cleanliness and appearance, and structural integrity.
• Those who attend the demonstration must not engage in any violent or threatening behavior and must abide by all state and federal laws and any applicable College policy.
• Those attending the protest/demonstration may be asked to show their College ID to prove their affiliation with the College.
• All attendees should be made aware of College policies at the beginning of the demonstration/protest.
• Demonstrators may not claim to speak for or otherwise represent the position of the College, unless officially sanctioned by the President or their designee.
• The College student code of conduct, residential life policies and/or other College policies, including health and safety policies,) must be observed at all times before, during, and after a demonstration event.
Communicating the Parameters
• All College policies must be observed at all times in the planning and conduct of the event.
• The organizer is responsible for communicating any parameters that have been set for the event by the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement to all participants prior to the event. The organizer will serve as the primary liaison with the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement or their designee during the event and ensure compliance with those parameters by all participants.
• The organizers of the demonstration event will work with the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement to reserve space on campus, arrange for Campus Security as necessary, and to discuss all related logistics.
• Demonstrations on campus must account for the potential involvement of outside entities such as the media and local law enforcement. Organizers should prepare for how these groups may influence the event, ensuring safety protocols are in place and that any interactions are handled in accordance with campus policies.
Presence of College Personnel
Student organizers should expect college personnel including Campus Security to be present for all or part of the event. This presence is often necessary to ensure organizers’ own rights are protected and the College’s regular operations and activities are not interrupted. Presence at an event by Le Moyne employees does not necessarily mean that they endorse or support the content of the expression provided at the demonstration.
Presence of Non-College Community Members
Non-College members of the community, including alumni, are not permitted to host, sponsor, or participate in a campus demonstration without the explicit permission of the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement. Guests at a demonstration will only be permitted if speaking at an event and if invited by the student organizers and in support of the free exchange of ideas. The guest must be registered with the Office of Student Engagement and must provide a copy of their identification card and disclosure of any organizations they represent. Campus guests are expected to follow all College policies; failure to do so may result in the issuance of a no-trespassing order and referral for charges to the local Police Department.
Conclusion of the Demonstration
The length of any given demonstration may vary. Demonstrations will generally be permitted to continue unless College officials determine that College operations or the rights of others have been compromised. This includes considerations for staff who may need to close facilities according to established building hours. Students are only allowed to occupy space during the reserved time and will not be permitted to demonstrate or protest overnight.
At the conclusion of any demonstration, student organizers are expected to make a reasonable effort to return the grounds or area to its original condition. This includes properly disposing of all trash. Any unanticipated or accidental property damage should be reported to College administrators immediately. Any property damage resulting from a demonstration—whether peaceful or disruptive—may lead to the assessment of fees for cleaning, repairs, or replacement of property, which may be charged to the responsible organization or individuals involved.
Procedure for demonstration requests that are not approved
In the event that a request to conduct a demonstration is not approved by the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement, the organizer may present a 1-2-page appeal letter to the Associate Provost for Student Development. All appeals should be sent to [email protected]. Upon review of an appeal, the Associate Provost for Student Development will inform the organizer of the final decision.
Procedures for Responding to Obstructive or Disruptive Demonstrations
To prevent misunderstandings about behavior that is considered acceptable (dissent) versus unacceptable (disruption), the following guidelines provide definitions and criteria:
• Dissent refers to individual or group activities that express grievances or seek changes within society, the campus, or both. Dissent can be broader than a single 7 grievance or remedy and may have an ideological basis. It typically involves proposed solutions as well as complaints and relies on persuasion.
• Disruption refers to activities that interfere with the rights of others. Unlike dissent, which is grounded in persuasion, disruption may involve harassment, coercion, or violence.
Specific examples of disruption include, but are not limited to:
• Infringing upon the rights of students, faculty, or staff within the College community.
• Disrupting or interfering with instruction, research, administration, or other College activities.
• Reacting to others' peaceful dissent in a way that attempts to deny their rights.
• Obstructing or restricting free movement of individuals on any part of the College campus.
• Denying the use of offices, classrooms, or other facilities to students, staff, or guests of the College.
• Endangering or threatening the safety of any persons or property on campus.
• Threatening others through inappropriate communication, gestures, or actions (including, but not limited to, pushing, intimidation, vulgar language, or bullying).
• Causing the destruction or defacement of property.
The College will communicate with event organizers before demonstrations to set clear expectations and to educate them on the differences between dissent and disruption. Mediation or dialogue may be offered if a demonstration is at risk of becoming disruptive. Any behaviors not explicitly listed here but deemed harmful or disruptive by College officials may also be considered violations.
Violations of the Policy
Event organizers will be notified if the protest guidelines have been violated. Upon the first notification, organizers will be given an opportunity to immediately comply with College guidelines. If a second violation occurs, organizers will be informed that the protest must cease and may need to be rescheduled. A follow-up educational meeting will be required with the Assistant Dean for Student Engagement and the group's advisor. Upon a third violation, Public Safety, and if necessary, local law enforcement (such as the local Police Department), will disband the protest, which could lead to arrests. Failure to comply with College personnel may result in a referral to the Office of Student Conduct and/or a criminal investigation.
Protests or demonstrations may be disbanded immediately if College policies are violated, including but not limited to acts of vandalism, significant disruption to campus operations, lewd or disrespectful speech, harassment or discrimination, interference by 8 non-College guests, or actions that endanger the safety and well-being of the College community.
(Policies by Fordham University, Fairfield University, University of Loyola at Chicago, Loyola University Maryland were consulted in the creation of this statement)
Last Updated, September 18, 2024